Things to do in NYC: 2 Day Itinerary in the Big Apple

New York City, the city that never sleeps! We visited New York City in March after visiting some family in upstate New York for a couple of days. It was very cold and a blizzard had blown through the week before our arrival. That said, the cold didn’t stop us from being excited about all the things to do in NYC.

We got to take a two hour train ride through beautiful, snow-covered upstate New York on our way to NYC.

Looking for things to do in NYC? Take the train upstate for some peace and beauty

Our ride was from Poughkeepsie to Grand Central Station. And so began our NYC adventure.

Things to Note About Our 2 Days in NYC

We walked almost everywhere we went. For instance, we ended our our first full day at 13.1 miles walked. We were a little tired, to say the least.

Walking is a great way to see all the things to do in NYC

The next day was another whopping 11 miles walked. Seems crazy now. However, this was the best decision we could have made, as it led to an amazing couple of days where we saw so many sights by happenstance and saved money on transportation! It led us to explore Chicago in a similar fashion. More on that in our post on things to do in Chicago in 3 days!

Unlike Chicago, we did not buy a CityPASS or Go Explorer Pass for NYC. Unfortunately, we didn’t even know these existed when we visited at the time! Sad day. These are a great deal and definitely worth checking out. However, it seems Go Explorer Pass beats the CityPASS for options and cost. You can compare them for yourself! 

Pro Tip: Don’t use your pass at the American Museum of Natural History. Admission is not a set price. We recommend “buying” your tickets at the counter, not online. You’re allowed to donate what you deem as appropriate for admission and then certain exhibits cost extra, like the planetarium.

Want to skip the story and just see the itinerary below? Click here!

Where to Stay in NYC

There are so many Airbnb’s in NYC, but technically, they’re illegal. That’s the case in a lot of places though and that didn’t stop us from at least trying. What stopped us from staying in an Airbnb in NYC was the fact that most hosts we found in Manhattan asked you to not disclose you’re a guest, to be discreet, or to avoid nosy neighbors.

We don’t blame the hosts; NYC is cracking down on Airbnb.

So we figured with the prices of Airbnb being pretty similar to some hotels to just forgo the secrets and stay in a hotel. If looking for lodging in the Big Apple, give Airbnb a shot. We’re sure there’s a great one out there. If not, Hotel Pennsylvania is a great, budget-friendly choice right near Penn Station!

Hotel Pennsylvania isn’t the fanciest or most luxurious but it’s got history (Darah’s grandma would have girls weekends here back in the day!) and was the best deal we could find in Manhattan. Its Google reviews aren’t the best either, but we thought it was perfect for our 2 day stay. We were barely in the room, after all! A bed to sleep, a place to shower, and Manhattan at our doorstep.

Things to do in NYC: Stay in Hotel Pennsylvania

The best part about Hotel Pennsylvania is the location. It’s right across the street from Penn Station and Madison Square Garden and a short walk to Times Square. Penn Station is a great connection for the NYC subway and you’re able to go anywhere from there! Turns out we didn’t use Penn Station too often and instead walked our butts off. More on that below…

Late Arrival to NYC: MOMA, Italian, and Times Square

Our train arrived after 4pm on a Friday so most of the day was lost, but there was still time to make something out of it! If you’re in need of something to do on a Friday evening or arrive in the late afternoon like we did then you should make your way to the Museum of Modern Art, MOMA.

On Fridays from 4pm to 8pm the museum is FREE for all visitors! Keep in mind that since it’s free admission the museum will be very crowded. So if that would ruin your experience then maybe it’s best for you to pay to go on another day.

For example, the crowd around Van Gogh’s Starry Night was enormous. Still a wonderful painting to see in person, even though you bump a few shoulders while waiting. Make sure to check it out!

After the MOMA we walked directly across the street to Mozzarella e Vino, a cozy Italian restaurant serving up delicious eats and fantastic wine. We started off with some Pecorino Toscano and Prosciutto di Parma. Their menu is seasonal but when we dined there we had the lasagna al forno and ravioli del giorno and they were incredible.

On our way back to Hotel Pennsylvania we caught our first glimpse of the bright and flashing lights of Times Square.

Things to do in NYC: Walk around Times Square

We walked around for a little while and entered some shops, even though shopping in these places isn’t our cup of tea. You can find these same shops in Vegas. the Magnificent Mile in Chicago, all over the world. We took in the sea of people and bright lights and once we’d had enough, we made our way to our warm bed.

Day 1: Lots to See and Do in the Big Apple!

We woke up bright and early so that we could get a jump start on our day. We made our way to Penn Station where we breakfasted on donuts and coffee and then hopped on a subway to South Ferry Station. Little did we know this would be our only subway ride of the day.

See the Statue of Liberty…For Free!

Ideally, we would have liked to go to the top of the statue but those tickets are booked months in advance. If you’re like us and you don’t see a point in paying to just go to Liberty Island then take the Staten Island Ferry. It’s free and runs frequently during the week.

You’ll get a great view of the Statue of Liberty as you make your way to Staten Island and then you’ll see her again as you make your return from Staten Island to Manhattan. You’ll also get awesome shots of NYC itself!

The Staten Island Ferry is a great way to see the Statue of Liberty, one of the best things to do in NYC

After you get to Staten Island, just exit the boat (everyone must), and then hop back in the line to get on. The ferry was spacious and there were great spots for pictures.

Looking for things to do in NYC? Take the Staten Island Ferry to see the Statue of Liberty

When we returned to Manhattan at 9am we had no idea what was next. No game plan. Our only obligation was to be in Little Italy by 5pm to eat dinner with Darah’s aunt and uncle, who live in Jersey.

Buried Treasure in Trinity Church

It didn’t talk long to figure out our next step as we looked up to the sky and our answer was shining in the clouds. Freedom Tower. It didn’t look like it was too far so we decided to walk there. We’re glad we did! If you walk to Freedom Tower from the Staten Island Ferry then you’ll get the chance to walk through Wall Street and see the Charging Bull. That’s not us, by the way.

The Charging Bull on Wall Street is a must when looking for things to do in NYC

There are other great historical stops on the way like Trinity Church. You know, the church where Nicolas Cage found billions of dollars worth of treasure buried underneath it by following a series of clues he found after stealing the Declaration of Independence. That church. It’s also where Alexander Hamilton is buried.

Things to do in NYC: Visit Trinity Church graveyard

There’s also St. Paul’s Chapel, where George Washington attended service while NYC served as the nation’s capital. There’s a statue of Benjamin Franklin nearby as well.

One the cool things to do in NYC, visit St. Paul's Chapel where George Washington went

Freedom Tower and 9/11 Memorial

After all the unexpected historical stops, we finally made it to Freedom Tower. We didn’t make it inside the 9/11 Memorial Museum itself but the fountain memorials outside are surreal, as is standing in the shadow of this massive building.

Things to do in NYC: Visit 9/11 Memorial Fountains

We were lucky enough to witness a fly-by where the military jets let off red, white and blue smoke.

Things to do in NYC: Freedom Tower Military Jet Fly by

Chinatown and Lunch

We found restrooms in Westfield World Trade Center, which is a vast shopping mall with some unique architecture, and then we set on our way to Chinatown for lunch!

Things to do in NYC: Shop at Westfield World Trade Center Mall

We wandered around, gawking at the unfamiliar markets and foods until we stopped at H.K. Wonton Garden. This small Chinese restaurant was just what the doctor ordered on this chilly day. Pork dumplings with soup and mushrooms and wontons with soup.

Things to do in NYC: eat in Chinatown at H.K. Wonton Garden

It’s quite funny in hindsight. This food seemed very foreign at the time, but just over a year later, after leaving the USA to move to Taiwan, we’ve seen a lot of the food that’s offered in Chinatown and much more.

Crossing the Brooklyn Bridge and NYU

Once you’re full on Chinese food you can walk to the Brooklyn Bridge. If you feel like it you can even go to the other side! We just walked halfway, got some great pictures and walked back.

Things to do in NYC: Cross the Brooklyn Bridge

We wandered around the area, grabbed snacks from food trucks and saw a couple of street performers. Then we made our way to the NYU campus and pretended like we were still in college. It’s a great campus to walk around and explore.

We would have loved to tour the inside of the library and other buildings but we weren’t allowed, being non-students. The campus is engulfed by trendy coffee shops and cafes so if you’re in the area and need to chill, you have plenty of options.

Then it was off to Little Italy for dinner!

Little Italy

Little Italy, which used to be quite large, has been slowly shrinking due to the surrounding neighborhoods like Chinatown taking over but there are still a lot of great eats and shops! We ate dinner at The Original Vincent’s and had the Veal Parmigiana and Linguine with shrimp.

Things to do in NYC: Eat and Shop in Little Italy

Manhattan at Night

Darah’s aunt and uncle were kind enough to drive us to Brooklyn after dinner so we could see Manhattan from across the river at night. It was a sight to see as we walked along the Brooklyn Heights Promenade. It was freezing cold but beautiful.

Walking the Brooklyn Heights Promenade is one of the best things to do in NYC

Empire State Building at Night

In our opinion, the best time to visit the Empire State Building is at night. One of the biggest cities in the world is alight below you. That said, it was March, pretty overcast, windy, and friggin cold. So we didn’t stay forever. Just long enough to savor the view. You practically have all night as it’s open until 2 am. Maybe your night will be warmer and the sky will be clear! You can use city card for the Empire State Building, which we recommend, or you can just buy tickets for the Empire State Building itself. They have several different experiences.

Things to do in NYC: Go to the top of the Empire State Building

Yes, we had so much Italian food and wine that we were about to burst. But that didn’t stop us from hitting up Papaya Dog (open 24 hours) when we made it back down to ground level.

Sleep…finally

Day 2: Another Fun Day of Exploring NYC!

American Museum of Natural History and Hayden Planetarium

We started our day at the American Museum of Natural History. This museum is massive and would take multiple days to see everything. Or maybe if we hadn’t walked 13 miles the day before we’d have had the energy to make it.

This museum, full of so many great exhibits, is technically “pay what you want” if you buy tickets at the counter but if you want to see any of the special exhibits then you have to pay for them separately. We purchased tickets to see the Dark Matter show narrated by Neil DeGrasse Tyson at Hayden Planetarium and would pay for it again. This was our best planetarium dome theater experience to date. It’s also the largest we’ve visited.

Things to do in NYC: Visit the American Museum of Natural History and see dinosaur skeletons

New York Style Pizza…It’s About Time!

After the museum we needed to refuel so we found the nearest pizza restaurant and enjoyed an entire pie of pepperoni pizza at Patsy’s Pizzeria. SO greasy…sooo good.

Central Park and Belvedere Castle

Central Park is better seen when it’s warmer and less grey, but we enjoyed it nonetheless. There’s so much nature in the middle of a huge city. There are cafes, recreational fields, gardens, and Belvedere Castle.

Central Park is a must-see site when looking for things to do in NYC

Belvedere Castle was built in the 19th century and was eventually used as an observation deck for meteorology. It’s a fun sight to visit and offers some great views of the park and city! Careful going up and down the spiral staircase; it’s a one-way street.

5th Avenue and Free Organ Concert

After Central Park we made our way to 5th Avenue. There’s a lot of great architecture to see while walking on 5th Avenue and a lot of high-end shopping (if that’s your thing). As we were walking down 5th Avenue we came across a church offering a free organ concert and stepped in. Turns out it was St. Thomas Church, a beautiful Gothic style building. We caught the last few songs and this turned out to be one of our favorite parts of the trip. Free music and a beautiful setting.

Things to do in NYC: Organ Concert at St. Thomas Church on 5th Avenue

St. Patrick’s Cathedral

St. Patrick’s Cathedral in New York City is famous and it was obvious why when we walked up and stood in its magnificent neo-Gothic shadow. We arrived during 4 o’clock mass so to avoid being rude, we left after a short time and unfortunately didn’t get a closer look. Even if you just saw the outside, St. Patrick’s is worth a visit.

With its breathtaking Gothic architecture, St. Patrick's Cathedral is one of the best things to do in NYC

Radio City Hall & Rockefeller Center

At this point we got off 5th Avenue and walked past Rockefeller Center, which has an observation deck you can visit with cool views of NYC. We think choosing this or Empire State, not both, is a good idea. Or if it’s the right season you can ice skate on their iconic rink.

Rockefeller Center and Skating Rink is one of the most fun things to do in NYC

If you walk to 50th Street and 6th Avenue then you’ll be able to see the entrance to Radio City Hall where if you’re lucky you can catch a concert or show. We would have loved to see a show here, but not this time around. We will try again in the future!

Things to do in NYC: Radio City Music Hall

BarBacon

This is exactly what it sounds like. A bacon bar. A bar resides in the center of the restaurant, surrounded by booths and tables. What’s on the menu? You guessed it. Bacon! This savory restaurant is one of many in Hell’s Kitchen.

Things to do in NYC: Eat bacon nachos at BarBacon

If you don’t feel like bacon then try going for Thai food. There are a ton of Thai restaurants in Hell’s Kitchen. We recommend Pure Thai Cookhouse. Reviews made it sound like a winner.

Our Itinerary for NYC in 2 Days

Day 0: Late Arrival

Check-in

Museum of Modern Art (Free from 4pm-8pm on Fridays)

Dinner – Mozzarella e Vino

Walk Times Square

Day 1 (Full Day)

Staten Island Ferry to get a great FREE view of the Statue of Liberty

Trinity Church

Freedom Tower and Westfield World Trade Center Mall

Lunch – Chinatown

Brooklyn Bridge

NYU Campus

Dinner – Little Italy

Brooklyn Heights Promenade and View of Manhattan

Empire State Building at Night

New York hot dog!

Day 2 (Full Day)

American Museum of Natural History

Lunch – New York style pizza

Central Park

Walk 5th Avenue

St Patrick’s Cathedral

Radio City Hall and Rockefeller Center

Dinner – Bar Bacon

Other Great Things to do in NYC!

Broadway

Broadway is a must for anyone visiting NYC but it is costly! Hamilton tickets were crazy expensive. If you don’t want to spend a lot then try waiting in line at a TKTS Booth at Times Square, Lincoln Center or South Street Seaport for discounted seats or you can try the online lottery for the show you want to see. We tried the online lottery but were unsuccessful 🙁

Things to do in NYC: See a show on Broadway

Yankees/Mets Game

We’ve seen someone sporting a Yankees hat in every destination in Asia and all over Europe. They’re a big deal. Catching a game, a dog, and a cold one with some great weather would be a good time!

Things to do in NYC: See a Yankee's game

The Met (Metropolitan Museum of Art)

This museum has artwork spanning over 5000 years and is the largest art museum in the United States. The MOMA was free admission so that’s why we went there instead. But the Met is where it’s at and where we’ll definitely go next time.

Guggenheim Museum

Here you’ll find a collection of impressionist, post-impressionist, early modern and contemporary art. The coolest part? This building was designed by Frank Lloyd Wright.

Things to do in NYC: Visit the Guggenheim Museum

Top of the Rock Observation Deck

The observatory you can visit at the top of Rockefeller Center. It’s a different viewpoint from the Empire State Building but not quite as high. Still a cool view! 

Sit in on a show (Saturday Night Live, Jimmy Fallon, Stephen Colbert, etc)

This takes some major planning ahead. You have to figure out when the lottery is for the upcoming season and enter it. You don’t get to pick the date or time of the show if you win the lottery so be prepared to plan your whole trip around it if you win.

Seeing Colbert is one of many great things to do in NYC

Summary of Things to Do in 2 Days in NYC

There are so many things to do in NYC. I mean, we’re just writing about Manhattan here. There are 5 boroughs! Word on the street is Brooklyn is the new Manhattan, so you may want to cross the river for a good time. No matter what your itinerary details are, you’re in for a treat in America’s biggest city!

Happy Travels!

Have you been to NYC before? Going soon? Comment below about your experience or what you plan to do! If you’ve been or are going in any other season than winter we envy you.

Like it? Pin it!

Things to do in NYC: Pin

 

Where Food Takes Us

We’re Darah and Garrett. Our life has been an adventure ever since we eloped in a pink Cadillac in Las Vegas. Now we’re running around the world, working online, and eating everything we can.

@WhereFoodTakesUsBlog
@WhereFoodTakesUsBlog
Start Your Travel Budget!Receive our FREE interactive trip itinerary and budget calculator!

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.